This discussion has taken off as Berkeley faculty call for leveraging the campus's unique strenghts in the downturn. This is thought to include a greater draw on out-of-state students than other UC campuses, and an ability to charge higher tuition. Others argue that higher tuition for a handful of the senior campuses would lead to the stratification of the system, wasteful competition, and a decline in quality for students overall. Nobody 's going to shift their current position much without an independent budget assessment of the impact of tuition hikes on the affected campus, which I call for here.
Some relevant documents:
The Futures Report, pp 29-34 on the Michigan scenario.
UCSF Professor Stan Glantz (Futures Report co-author) on Restoring the Master Plan
UCB Professor David A. Hollinger on more out-of-state students for Berkeley
UCSB Professor Chris Newfield's comments on the budgetary issues involved in a "Michiganization" analysis
UCB Professor Chris Rosen on studying budgets and subsidies
Hollinger's response to Newfield
UCLA Prof. Michael Meranze on the privatization debate
Exchange between Newfield and Judith Innes on budget studies
- Research Website
- Why I Restarted This Blog
Christopher Newfield
UC Daily Links
Book
Chicago Tribune review | Chronicle of Higher Ed interview
The Atlantic article | SB Independent articles 1 and 2
LARB review | John McGowan review | Decasia review
Radical Teacher review | Salon analysis | Public Books review
Future Trends interview | Full Stop interview pt 1 and 2
symplokē review | Change Magazine review
Frequent Labels
Labels
- ACCJC vs. CCSF (1)
- Academic Freedom (56)
- Academic Labor (57)
- Academic Senate (29)
- Admin Responses (154)
- Administrative Overreach (22)
- Affordability (27)
- Athletics (5)
- Austerity (45)
- Budget (297)
- Cal State (28)
- California (49)
- Campus Safety (33)
- Closures (2)
- Community College (12)
- Cooper Union (1)
- Corruption (5)
- Costs (71)
- Crisis (152)
- Cuts (110)
- Development (19)
- Discrimination (8)
- Diversity (7)
- Economy (7)
- Employee Benefits (39)
- Faculty (98)
- Financial Aid (13)
- For-Profit (9)
- Funding Model (131)
- Furlough (12)
- Future University (27)
- Governance (64)
- Graduates (10)
- Humanities (31)
- Income (33)
- Inequality (44)
- International (19)
- Isla Vista Shootings (3)
- Janet Napolitano (38)
- Jerry Brown (43)
- K-12 (2)
- Liberal Arts (15)
- Management (49)
- Margaret Spellings (2)
- Mark Yudof (19)
- November 2009 (1)
- Online Education (42)
- Pension (19)
- Politics (71)
- Privatization (42)
- Protests (79)
- Public Funding (93)
- Public vs. Private (76)
- Quality (27)
- Race (24)
- Religion & Culture (5)
- Research (34)
- STEM (10)
- Shared Governance (37)
- Steven Salaita (6)
- Strategies & Goals (59)
- Students (61)
- Tenure (10)
- Transparency (15)
- Tuition Hikes (28)
- UC (243)
- UC Berkeley (39)
- UC Care (18)
- UC Davis (17)
- UC Irvine (4)
- UC Los Angeles (6)
- UC Regents (81)
- UC Riverside (11)
- UC Santa Barbara (25)
- UCOF (21)
- UCOP (64)
- Unions (19)
- University of Missouri (1)
- University of Wisconsin System (8)
- Vegara vs. California (1)
All Posts
All Posts
-
▼
2009
(216)
-
▼
August
(45)
- What's the Matter with UCOP?
- UCSB Call for Campus Response to UCOP Furlough Ruling
- UCOP Mandate Morally and Politically Unacceptable
- UC Berkeley Shortens Teaching Term
- The Faculty Stands Alone
- UCOP on Furloughs: We're the Deciders!
- Chris Newfield in Chronicle not today but some ten...
- From UC-AFT: Call for No Confidence Vote
- Turn it around; don’t give it away: AAUP Statement...
- Letter to Gary Strong, UCLA University Librarian
- And Sometimes We Get Boethian Dream Visions
- University of North Carolina Administration Grows ...
- on-line education, the 11th campus
- Who Are the High Earners in the UC System (x-post)
- Byron Williams: University of California Regents d...
- We Get Letters: UCSC Loses Its Child Care
- University of Southern Miss is considering the eli...
- Should Berkeley Be Michigan? Dialgoue on Privatiza...
- Emerging Furlough Standards and Goals
- I Have Some Questions
- Sign Up Time
- The Economist Takes Notice
- Option Four Videos of Yudof Q & A and Lisa Hajjar ...
- CSU Chancellor in SF Chronicle
- News from the Santa Barbara Yudof Protests
- Robert Samuels' blog, "Changing Universities"
- SF Chronicle: Execs Still Get Raises
- Recession Realities in Higher Education
- Indeed, "what of the children?"
- So...what business are we in again?
- We Sometimes Get Letters Addressed to Other People
- Show Me the Money
- Another great piece by Jeffrey Wasserstrom
- UC / CSU budget cuts from Associated Press (correc...
- Option 4: 1st Annual Bad Business Award
- Please read Gerry's 2nd comment in previous post
- The Real Reasons to Support Language Study
- We Get Letters: On Dean Edley's Distance Learning ...
- From CUCFA: Legal Update on The Emergency
- Robert Williams: Press Conference Statement (7/29)
- Robert Samuels: Giving Up on Education at UCLA?
- Option 4: Follow the Money
- Marc Bousquet on the Rise of the Executive Class i...
- Michael Meranze, "Jefferson's Epitaph"
- Charlie Schartz, "Do Public Colleges Rip Off Stude...
-
▼
August
(45)
Blogroll
- Academic Jobs Wiki
- Calitics
- Campaign for the Public University (UK)
- Changing Universities
- Citizen of Somewhere Else (SUNY Issues)
- Cloudminder
- Critical Education (UK)
- Easily Distracted (Timothy Burke)
- Edu-Factory
- Exquisite Life (UK)
- Higher Ed Watch
- Higher Education - The Guardian (UK)
- Homeless Adjunct
- Humanities Think Talk
- In Socrates' Wake
- Keep California's Promise
- Magna Charta Observatory (Bologna)
- New Deal for the Humanities
- New Faculty Majority
- Occupy Colleges
- Postgraduate Worker (UK)
- PrawfsBlawg
- Quality Public Higher Education
- Recession Realities in Higher Education Blog
- Reclaim UC
- Reclamations
- Sciences Carré Blog (France)
- Student Activism
- Texas Tribune - Higher Ed
- The California Professor
- The Quick and the Ed
- UC Faculty Supporting Students
- UC Pay Search Tool
- UCLA Faculty Association Blog
- Universitas (France)
- University Diaries (Margaret Soltan)
- University of Oregon Matters
- University Probe
- We Are Not Rats (Scotland)
4 comments:
On Privatization in California vs Privatization in Michigan, note this difference between California and Michigan:
In Michigan, there are two or three major universities: U of M at Ann Arbor, Michigan State, and Wayen State. Of these, U of M Ann Arbor is the only truly major research national and international research university. When U of M Ann Arbor tilted toward privatization, it had no competition in-state.
Now California. A privatized UC system or a privatized Berkeley or UCLA or UCSD would enter a field already dominated by Stanford and, secondarily, USC. No privatized UC entity could compete with Stanford or USC for financial aid or resources for faculty.
Unlike in Michigan, privatizing the UC system or its self-indulgently topmost parts (UCB, UCLA, UCSD) would leave the campuses at a competitive disadvantage.
Yes, I think accepting more out of state students is an option to consider. But a more extensive privatization is far from a cure-all. A truly realistic assessment would demand more skepticism of the economic and competitive feasibility of this option than Hollinger allows.
Michigan State has been moving up since UM privatized. It is probably now comparable to UC Davis. Disclaimer: I'm an MSU alumnus, so my data may be biased by the propaganda they distribute to their alumni.
I think that there is a way that "privatization" could work. If UC charged all students the same---the full cost of educating them, with now "return to aid" tax, and the state provided funds ONLY in the form of financial aid to students.
This would leave the Regents free to set the tuition level honestly at the real price, and make it very clear to the politicians what their money is buying---how many students they are supporting and how much they are supporting each one.
The University of Michigan has not and will not privatize. See www.ur.umich.edu/0809/Apr27_09/21.php
Michigan would play a predominant role in the eastern half of the Midwest.
Join the Conversation
Note: Firefox is occasionally incompatible with our comments section. We apologize for the inconvenience.