![]() |
Lisbon on November 10, 2026 |
For most academics, mega tech conventions are a parallel universe, but one worth visiting because its people partially control our own.
I’m just back from three days at Europe’s Web Summit: this one took place in the middle of the Nvidia chip trafficking scandal and CEO Jensen Huang’s fall to earth. What I saw and heard is trouble for their world, and ours.
Some background: Web Summit was founded and is still run by Paddy Cosgrave, first in Dublin and now in Lisbon. It has a reputation for combining tech marketing & dealmaking with progressive politics on issues like environmental sustainability and data policy—and also geopolitics (some big tech sponsors forced Cosgrave to resign in 2023—as it turned out, temporarily--for tweeting about Israel in Gaza that “War crimes are war crimes even when committed by allies”).
Around 70,000 people go annually to Lisbon to hear 1000 speakers and see another 1000 company exhibits, if that’s the word for installations that are bigger than most people’s apartments. Talks are divided into streams with names like AI Summit, New Media Summit, Venture Summit, Corporate Innovation Summit, Startup Showcase, Health Summit, Creative Summit, and Policy Summit. The flagship talks are at Center Stage, held in the city’s MEO sports arena in a corporate part of the city I’d previously ignored, while the rest happens simultaneously in 4 enormous pavilions lined up one after the other like airport terminals. All the other “summit” talks happen in the very large corners of these fulfillment-center-sized spaces or in country and company pavilions. It’s basically tech Disneyland—you can barely imagine how crowded it is, or how carefully organized.
The dream of the 90s is alive in Lisbon. At Web Summit we still have a booming knowledge economy and tech is the eternal fountainhead of all positive social change.
Companies are looking for venture capital and middle-income countries are looking for companies. Companies are selling basic commercial infrastructure—payment systems, communications tools, AI-based government services—to countries that can’t or won’t build them with public money and their own skill base. Hundreds of (very small) companies are looking for angel investors or other early-round funding. Smaller countries don’t want the knowledge economy to be over (as the running down of universities in France, the US and the UK suggests it is). Knowledge economies, for all their problems, are seen as the only way out of a combination of resource extraction and local services.
As the AI bubble deflates, and gods like Jensen Huang are hurled from the heavens, the summit was haunted by signs that real progress is sociocultural and makes use of tech: it is not decided and defined by tech as such. But in the summit hangers it’s the Long Nineties still.
I’m going to focus on the structural issues. The last 2 cut against the first 7.
1. 25 minutes, no questions. The speaker model is not the university lecture or seminar but the TED Talk. It’s a 20th century broadcast model with a live studio audience. Good or bad, no ideas got challenged, discussed, tested, or extended. One result: repetition and conformity structures the discourse system.
2. Mediatized intellectuality. Tech has captured media and media believes that it owns thought communication, the communication of all the thought that matters. Talks are messages with “noise” removed, meaning they remove the things that academia exists to explore: anomalies, doubts, ambiguities, contradictions that lead to new ideas. The medium is the marketing. People no doubt notice this, but the production values overwhelm resistance. The money behind the spectacle makes thinking small. And poor. See the tiny people under the sign.
3. The Unbearable Lightness of Novelty. Originality has been hollowed out. The more you say the word the less there is. I liked all the people I met and completely sympathize with the ones, especially millennials and Gen Xers, trying to get recognition for their brainchild business in this insanely crowded and brutally stratified tech world.
Even so, I couldn’t find products on the floor that surprised me. The same was true of nearly all the talks (exceptions discussed below), which were pitches converging around the same handful of themes that ratified tech’s benevolent transformations of society that yield users and riches. I saw a lot of minor variations on similar products. Which gets us to:
4. The AI revolution has been commodified. I was impressed by the number of companies selling rigs and tools on top of apparently interchangeable foundation models. Mikayel Vrdanyan, of Armenia and Miami, co-founded a company called Picsart with 130 million users of its image and video generator services, and it deploys 240 foundation models. What the hell is actually going on in there? We’re coming up on the 4th anniversary of the era-defining release of ChatGPT. At Web Summit I was awash in undifferentiated content from an AI industry about which the percentage of people saying they are “more excited than concerned” hovers internationally around 15%. There was so much energy, and so much inertia. One symptom:
5. The fetishization of storytelling. I too think storytelling is a key to consciousness and change, but then I heard every single speaker in the Creative Summit harp on this term. What does it mean? I learned that it means the human. It means the heart (Bill Gross of IDEO’s favorite word.) Everyone—literally everyone—said you need to connect with people and to do that you need to bring them the story that draws on your human experience.
On a panel called “The Next Chapter of Storytelling,” film maker Ashley Schlaifer said, “we can’t let the humanity go as we use AI. Everyone should be using AI and making it native to your workflow [the standard disclaimer]. Use it to bring them experience.”
On “Inside the Creative Collaborator Era,” the founder of “Flawless AI,” film maker Scott Mann, denounced “generative AI as bringing in someone else’s work as you own, that is, stealing.” His company uses AI to modify human video and images but not to generate them from scratch. “What’s real takes practice,” he pointed out. He added, “Living life is the value. I lived a bit more and learned to pull from that.”
Sometimes I cheered them on for using storytelling to break tech determinism. But this discourse needs a lot more cognitive and practice-based content. People are fighting the AI truisms of 2026 with the empowerment truisms of 1976, which felt like another mode in which AI ensures cultural stagnation.
2026 and 1976 have a shared problem:
6. It’s the talent, not the education. I love podcasts, and then I went to some podcast panels. The talks focused on the Darwinist showbusiness sorting I recognize from my LA youth. There were two topics: finding stars; inserting stars into podcast production companies (Fox, Vox) as the new studio system where the platform is a one-stop production shop with a built-in audience. There wasn’t a word about developing unknown people: you pitch the platform executives and they swipe you right or left. The speakers' goal was to advertize the popularity of their platform.
None of the speakers had a story about how they made somebody better at something—at analyzing, speaking, interviewing, finding co-hosts and guests, etc. There was nothing about gaps in content they’d like to fill. The panels didn’t offer a word about the training they do to get a range of different kinds of people on the air. There wasn’t a word about meaningful cultural diversity. These media people were completely focused on existing celebrities—getting a film star (like Charlie Sheen) to do a podcast, “though that’s not a guarantee.” How do you develop a distinctive interest? How do you learn to have something to say about it? It dawned on me that these panels weren't about how to develop content but how to be a content executive.
Meanwhile, podcasting has arguably pulled ahead of blogging as the main media through which university people teach a wider public: Matt Seybold’s American Vandal, Lauren LeSabre-Shepherd’s American Campus, and Adrian Daub and Moira Donegan’s In Bed with the Right, are three superb examples. But at Web Summit, podcasts eclipse and for many people replace universities as the site of learning with some of the depth that was squeezed out by visual media (exemplified by Daniel Devnir's The Dig). But the media-tech model is, find Kara Swisher already in print at the New York Times, discover she’s good as a podcast host, put her on the air and then look for the next Kara Swisher. Swisher is a very skilled host, yet her show with Scott Galloway, Pivot, covers the same stories as Pod Save America, which covers the same stories as The Ezra Klein Show—somehow Matt and Lauren, Adrian and Moira and Dan, who cover different stories, didn’t get invited.
We're in the middle of a media content collapse and one big reason is that capitalist media structures like that now absorbing podcasts couldn't care less about the education pipeline. After 40 years of tech’s total narrative control, including control over definitions of desirable social change, people need to be helped and taught to develop their “human powers” to tell other stories. To repeat, not a thought was given to the educational pipeline. Web Summit was the first time since 1981 that I've gone three days without hearing one utterance of the word “university.”
7. Democratization, the Cover Story. Tech has been saying forever that the simplification of tools, accompanied by large price drops, gives the media’s power to the people. “You can make a feature film with your iPhone now!” In fact, tech has created industry concentration that insures no one will see your iPhone movie unless you’ve managed to fly all the way up to the platform level. The viral exceptions prove the rule. Democracy means, most simply, one person one vote. That is the opposite of today’s laws of algorithmic knowledge circulation in the industries that intensify unequal distribution of audiences. (Nicholas Carr has an excellent short history of "The Democratization Fallacy" as Chapter 6 of Superbloom.) Democratization is a sociocultural and political process, not a tech-communication effect.
8. The Persistence of Human Agency. There is a mild-mannered but pervasive anti-AI (anti-Superintelligence) backlash going on at the sub-mogul levels of the industry. This appeared in two forms. The first was market research, in the mode of social psychology. It shows what polls like Pew’s show, which is that people use AI tools as complements to their skills but hate it as replacements for them (the superintelligence thesis). One interesting panel presented work from a partnership between Metalab and a Columbia University scholar, Emily Goligoski, who summarized her research with this slide while Angie Amlani of Metalab looked on.
People want to retain four elements in their relation with this tech (small print) –autonomy, judgment, competence, and meaning. It is a big deal to point this out in summit world. Goligoski found people consistently ask this set of questions (big print). People want the outcome of their work with AI tools to be their choice, to come from a process they judged, via capabilities they have, where their thinking matters.
None of this will surprise you the reader, but in AI land it needs to be said again and again and with the gold seal of academic science attached.
It also needs to be said that when we ask people what they actually want, they point to an AI Plan B, in which these extremely expensive models and their data apparatus support a set of (powerful) tools for short cuts through people’s routine rather than creative or complex tasks. Meanwhile, AI’s Plan A remains hundreds of trillions of dollars coming from the capture or replacement of the systems underlying human consciousness, including those for open thought and democracy. Web Summit followed the script in saying we can have both. Research like Goligoski’s correctly says we have to choose.
9. Social benefits come from social action, not technology.
Society found a home in Pavillion 4 Stage 11, the designated sandbox of the Policy Summit and a portal to the Outside. There was a panel on “America after the midterms,” with David Sirota and others; “A Jewish history of anti-Zionism” with Benjamin Moser; "Open Source, open collaboration, shared benefits: Making AI work for all humanity," by Chinese government official Qi Xiaoxia, and “What does anti-imperalism mean today” with Amazon labor organizer Chris Smalls, among others.
I had two favorites. One featured economists James Galbraith and Daniela Gabor. Daniela is the PI of ISRF’s project Redesigning Finance for Climate Justice, and told the audience, in a nice way, that Europe needs to use government to discipline private capital or its tech is toast. China has built its green tech dominance with a complex system of government guidance funds, public capital and disciplined private capital (a key paper is here). Europe (and North America’s) climate future depends on building much better public institutions that steer resources towards public goals, not just more tech.
The second was “The power of protest”: Smalls came back to join two leaders of the French school protests, Nathanaël Combary and Soumaya Sarré, who explained why they’d blockaded their schools and taken to the streets. "Our schools are really bad," Sarré said. "The roof caved in during class at one school in St. Denis. This has been a problem for years and the government never fixes anything." Combary agreed: "We aren’t at the bargaining table so the government doesn’t do anything for us," he said. The host asked about student violence. Sarré said really it’s almost all police and the traditional media doesn’t report it, but students are angry: “it’s been years since we’ve been demanding the same things. Any violence is the result of our anger at years of nothing.”
Smalls chimed in with context. “One thing all this tech can’t solve is school conditions. Their kids’ education stays poor. These students give me motivation to keep doing this. I’m here for the whole working class. What you see is international solidarity: that’s the only thing that works.”
He said some words that I hadn’t heard on the other stages. “These students, they’re asking for better roofs, better food, better heating, some airconditioning, enough teachers. A lot of them need housing—there’s a housing crisis in Lisbon too. They aren’t asking for much. There's all this tech here, and money here, and investors. Invest in these kids, which is how you invest in the future.”
It was a great panel. It’s bad we have to demand, “invest in people,” but we do.
These latter panels knew all about the social foundations of learning and knowledge. They need to be made central to the tech, media, AI, creative, and marketing summits, that is, to the money summits within the summit--and to all state policy for tech.








0 comments:
Join the Conversation
Note: Firefox is occasionally incompatible with our comments section. We apologize for the inconvenience.