I will have some specific things to say about the guidelines below but first I want to sketch some context. I don't think that we can really understand the meaning of the guidelines without that. I should say before I go any further that, although I am going to be pointing to ways that the guidelines may function to intimidate faculty and reduce both academic freedom and free speech, I do not think that this was the intent of the drafters. And there are some helpful aspects to them. But that makes it even more important that the conversation be open and that we get this right.
As you may remember, in the summer of 2024 in response to legislative pressure, and then in the winter of 2025 in response to regental upset, then President Drake and then Provost Newman instituted a process to review both the Faculty Code of Conduct (APM 015) and the University Policy on Academic Conduct and the Administration of Discipline (APM 016). A joint Senate-Administration Workgroup was established in January of 2025.
Importantly, two separate impulses shaped this initiative. The first, which came from both the legislature and some regents as well as senior management, grew out of opposition to the Pro-Palestinian encampments of the Spring of 2024 and the feeling on the part of some legislators and regents that faculty, staff, and students who had participated in, or supported, the encampments had not been punished adequately when they were alleged to have violated university policy. The second emanated from the Regents and focused on the time it might take to complete a disciplinary process. As far as I can tell, although there was some overlap here with the first, the longer term issue was that the Regents, who in general only see the most severe and egregious violations of law and policy, were upset about how long it took to fire people.
In the end, the workgroup concluded that the policies embodied in APM 015 and 016 were sufficient regarding expressive activities or materials in classes. But they did propose the creation of a system where under some circumstances--relating to time guidelines--privilege and tenure hearing panels might be constituted by faculty from other campuses chosen by the systemwide senate. The policy would remain the same guidelines but guidelines for the infliction of discipline and guidance for understanding those guidelines would be created. For the guidelines see here at 52. The guidance is what is being reviewed now.
There are a couple of things worth noting here.
First, the expansion of systemwide senate intrusion into the constitution of local hearing committees effectively accepted the long-standing administration claim that it was senate practices that slowed down the disciplinary process. I have been hearing this claim for nearly two decades and have yet to see any systematic data that would demonstrate this claim. Given that there is an equally long standing discourse pointing to how long it takes for administrations to act (and given that administrations often give themselves extensions) it is hard to understand this step except as an effort to reduce the importance of local understandings and traditions--especially around expressive activities and the classroom. As it happens, I was recently reminded that one of the aspects of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 was that by empowering federal officials it limited the ability of local juries to protect those who had freed themselves. I know that the underlying situations aren't comparable. But the effect of centralizing to override local custom and practice is worth thinking about.
Second, although the idea of providing a guidance diagram for discipline under APM 016 modeled on similar efforts relative to sexual violence and sexual harassment (SVSH) and discrimination (DPO) violations appears reasonable, in reality it is filled with contradictions. It is true that SVSH and DPO may occasion defenses based in either academic freedom or free speech (especially in those cases of alleged Title 6 or Title 9 violations), the problems of expressive activity and classroom materials and inextricably embedded in academic freedom and First Amendment issues. There may be some clear cut cases such as a clear threat or spending an entire course talking about your family issues rather than the course materials, most cases are more open ended and given the way that discipline is handed out at UC and elsewhere codification may work to limit freedom more than arbitrary power. That is especially the case when the guidance is as explicitly focused on political questions as the proposed FAQs are.
Take for instance question 3 on whether a faculty member can be punished for reposting something that had led to punishment at another university. The guidance correctly points out that what happens at another university is not relevant to whether it could be disciplined at UC. It also correctly points out, however, that if the reposted material "would itself constitute a true threat or harassment, would misappropriate the
research of others, or would otherwise violate APM - 015" it might constitute a justification of discipline. But none of these things are limited to "controversial material" or what the guidelines are addressing as "expressive activities" in any meaningful sense. No matter what you are engaged in, if you express a "true threat or harassment," commit plagiarism or misuse someone's research or violate 015 (whatever that means in this specific instance) you could be charged with a violation. This is already a violation regardless of the context of the speech. The only reason for linking it to "controversial matters and controversial speech" (and what does that mean really, a new argument on the relationship of slavery and capitalism in the American Historical Review?) to these sorts of general violations is if the university is going to put extra pressure on political speech. The guidelines may think that they are simply providing clarification but they are also placing speech under a new and intensified spotlight.
Or take for example, Question 16 on whether a faculty member might be subject to discipline for canceling a discussion section to join a political protest (the guidance suggests discussion sections for the course are mandatory under normal circumstances). But this is deeply problematic. Would you be subject to discipline if you canceled a class for a family emergency? To present a scholarly paper at a conference? Unless the university is going to start disciplining everyone who cancels a class for whatever purpose it can't cancel a class because the motivation is political. Should the university be able to discipline a professor for a class cancellation?
I don't have a problem with expecting faculty to focus course time and material on the topic of the course. But the judgement of how that is done cannot be reduced to a set of guidelines. Nor, given recent history do I think that the Senate or faculty want to provide administrators (who have always had the final say in the imposition of discipline) a way to claim that a set of guidelines justified their decision that something was a "significant" intrusion of unrelated material into a class. I think that the authors of the guidelines have tried to create a balanced document but it's effect I fear will be to tighten discipline on faculty teaching and extramural speech. Again, take question 16. The FAQs include a series of actions that "may" result in discipline. I suspect that the authors intended these examples to indicate only potential risk. But given history does anyone doubt that administrators "may" take this example as authority to discipline? I have already heard of at least one case of a faculty member withdrawing from a review because of fear of discipline for canceling a class during the encampment. Another colleague asked me if these guidelines were supposed to encourage "anticipatory obedience." I couldn't in confidence say no.
I would urge everyone to read the guidelines and ask if a non-political equivalent to the example is possible. Then ask why it is only political examples that are used. And then write to the Academic Senate.
0 comments:
Join the Conversation
Note: Firefox is occasionally incompatible with our comments section. We apologize for the inconvenience.